Clinical reasoning
Asking the right question is half of a diagnosis. When someone says “I’m in pain,” that is the start of the interview, not the end of it.
Doctors, nurses, and physician assistants use a tool called OLDCARTS to get a fuller picture of a symptom, especially pain. Middle school and high school students can learn it before anyone hands them a white coat.
The questions
| Letter | Stands for | What you ask |
|---|---|---|
| O | Onset | When did it start? |
| L | Location | Where is it? Can you point with one finger? |
| D | Duration | How long does it last? Constant, or on and off? |
| C | Character | What does it feel like? Sharp, dull, burning? |
| A | Aggravating | What makes it worse? Movement, eating, something else? |
| R | Relieving | What makes it better? Rest, medicine, a position? |
| T | Timing | Does it come and go? Is it worse at night? |
| S | Severity | How bad is it, usually on a scale from 1 to 10? |
OLDCARTS keeps an interview from stopping at “it just hurts.” The answers belong in the Subjective section of a SOAP note, and they are what a hypothesis has to explain.
A sample interview
Chief complaint: stomach pain
- Onset. “It started last night.”
- Location. “Mostly the lower right side of my belly.”
- Duration. “It has been constant since it started.”
- Character. “Sharp and stabbing.”
- Aggravating. “It hurts more when I walk or move.”
- Relieving. “Lying still helps a little.”
- Timing. “No specific time. It has just been there.”
- Severity. “About a 7 out of 10.”
From there a student can write the Subjective piece of a SOAP note and hold more than one idea — appendicitis is one possibility, not the only one, until the rest of the findings are in.
This is the same pair of tools students used at Medical Detective Day.
Academy stories explain how clinicians learn to think. They are not medical advice, and they are not a diagnosis.
